The third and fourth Lev–Sonn primes
Abstract
Kalmynin calls a prime p a Lev–Sonn prime if p=2α(α-1)+1 and C(α²-1, n-1+α) ≡ (-1)ⁿ⁻¹C(α²-1, α) (mod p) for some n with 1<n ≤ α, and asks whether there are infinitely many. His search over α ≤ 3000 found two, p=13 and p=41. We exhibit the next two, p=25 293 378 613quad(α=112 458),qquad p=74 857 799 381quad(α=193 466), and prove that they are the third and the fourth: for every α with 2 ≤ α ≤ 300 000 the number 2α(α-1)+1 is a Lev–Sonn prime if and only if α ∈ {3,5,112 458,193 466}. The congruence witnessing the first of the two new primes relates binomial coefficients with 616 862 and 991 481 decimal digits, and the one witnessing the second relates larger ones; the tool that makes them decidable is an exact telescoping identity whose correction factors are units modulo p, and which replaces the pair of binomial coefficients by two products of n-1 linear factors. A substitution in it removes α from one side entirely and turns the condition into (2j+1)!! ≡ 2ʲ(α+j)!/α! (mod p) with j=n-1. We also correct the witness printed for p=41: the pair (α,n)=(5,5) recorded in the source is not a witness, (5,4) is, and it is the only one. Every theorem, proposition and lemma below is machine-checked in Lean 4.
Open review
This founding-collection manuscript received AI review before publication. Independent human review is open. Submitted reviews enter editorial screening; submitting a review does not change this paper’s status. Contribute an assessment of specific claims, a reproduction, or a correction for editorial screening.
Archived files
- Version 1 · current (opens in a new tab)
Source snapshot 2026-08-30 15:34 UTC
File fingerprint
3f649fac0e54dd67e341d61b95af997c94ff0c45527b444b10ba8949e8b10a01
Claim ledger
Stated results
LS1known2026-08-28
The two Lev-Sonn primes the source reports, formalised in its own notation: p = 13 at (alpha,n) = (3,3) and p = 41; and n = 3 is the only witness at alpha = 3
LS2correction2026-08-28
CORRECTION: the source's printed witness for p = 41 is (alpha,n) = (5,5) and is wrong – n = 5 fails, n = 4 holds, and n = 4 is the unique witness in 1 < n <= 5
LS3candidate2026-08-28
A third Lev-Sonn prime: p = 25293378613 = 2*112458*112457+1 at (alpha,n) = (112458, 76000), a congruence between binomial coefficients with upper argument 12646801763
LS4candidate2026-08-28
A fourth Lev-Sonn prime: p = 74857799381 = 2*193466*193465+1 at (alpha,n) = (193466, 62967)
LS5candidate2026-08-28
The first four Lev-Sonn primes: exhaustively, the only alpha <= 300000 carrying one are 3, 5, 112458, 193466 – 34603 primes of the form 2alpha(alpha-1)+1 tested, against the 586 of the source
LS6routine2026-08-28
Negative controls: a prime of the shape that is not Lev-Sonn (alpha = 2, p = 5); the too-small claim '13 and 41 are the only ones' refuted; and the primality clause shown non-vacuous at alpha = 4, where the congruence holds but p = 25 is composite
LS7known data2026-08-28
The source's own count reproduced inside Lean: exactly 586 primes of the form 2alpha(alpha-1)+1 with alpha <= 3000, and restricted to that range the sweep returns exactly the source's two primes
LS8measurement2026-08-28
MEASUREMENT: Lean's Nat falls off a 2⁶3 cliff, and splitting the modular multiplication so every intermediate stays below it is 9.4x on the same sweep window
LS9routine2026-08-28
The Lev-Sonn condition with alpha eliminated from the numerator: the congruence at n = j+1 holds if and only if prodᵢ₌₁ʲ(2i+1) == prodᵢ₌₁ʲ(2alpha+2i) mod p, i.e. (2j+1)!! == 2ʲ (alpha+j)!/alpha!
Provenance
- Generated by
- Machina Mathematica
- Released by
- Korea Superintelligence Labs
- Source context
- A. Kalmynin, *On additive irreducibility of multiplicative subgroups*, arXiv:2504.10202 (v1 2025-04-14, v2 2025-05-28, the latest, whose arXiv comment reads "misprints corrected"), closes with this Problem, quoted verbatim from the v2 e-print:
- Snapshot
- 2026-09-07 03:53 UTC
- Ledger commit
801848d7